logo
 
Blogs

Storm Induced Urban Flooding: The causes, Risks, Simulation and Prevention

Michael Zhang, Merivale High School, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada; Yousheng Zhang, GreenRideau Environmental Solution Inc., Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Abstract :

Storm Induced urban flooding is often referred as pluvial flooding (heavy rainfall-related flooding that is independent of an overflowing body of water), one of the major threats to people living in an urban area. This paper reviewed common causes and typical risks of storm induced urban flooding, and provided a summary of urban flooding models used to predict the flooding events to prevent the potential risks.

  1. Background

    Urban flooding is often referred as a type of pluvial flooding. It often occurs where it rains very hard over a short time frame [1]. On July 20, 2021, Zhengzhou, the provincial capital of Henan Province of China, recorded 201.9 millimeters (7.95 in) of rainfall within an hour, the highest ever figure recorded since measurements began in the city in 1951. The death toll of the flood was 398[2]. The flood also caused the evacuation of 815,000 people, and affected 14.5 million people around the province.[1] On 14 and 15 July 2021, a flood event affected parts of Belgium, Germany and surrounding countries, causing more than 200 fatalities and resulting in large socioeconomic impacts [3]. The intensity of the flood was believed to have been amplified by extreme weather caused by climate change[2]. With the global warm up, the climate change resulted urban flooding will likely be more common and more destructive [1]. Based on a report from Canada [1], this type of flooding often costs millions of dollars annually, and had hit the following communities: Windsor, Sydney, Chestermere, Burlington, Toronto, Calgary, and Binbrook in Canada.

  2. Causes of Urban Flooding

    Urban flooding is caused by excessive runoff in developed areas where water has no place to go, overloading both engineered and/or non-engineered drainage systems [1].

    1. Intensive Storm/Rainfall

      With the progress of climate change, more and more extreme weather conditions including extreme intensive storms/rainfall events were reported. The flood in ZhenZhou China on July 20, is one of the examples [2].

    2. Extreme large amount of surface runoff

      The intensive storm/rainfall combined with low ratio of grass coverage and high ratio of impervious surfaces built-up areas (like concrete, asphalt and large roofs) and by the overall concentration of development [1] often generates high amount of fast-moving surface runoff that turned streets into killer rivers.

    3. Under designed or not well-maintained stormwater drainage systems

      Urban flooding is often caused by intensive rain that falls on impervious surfaces and overwhelms local stormwater drainage capacity. Each of these components—heavy precipitation (which is expected to become more frequent due to climate change), increased urbanization that increased impervious areas, and insufficient or outdated stormwater infrastructure that reduced drainage capacity—presents a challenge in and of itself[5].

  3. Typical Risks of Urban Flooding

    Urban flooding events can be extremely dangerous, especially when fast-moving water rapidly fills streets, homes, and buildings before people can safely evacuate [6]. It also creates stress for homeowners due to the financial strain, emotional stress, and hardships of temporarily living in a damaged home, and exposes people to a variety of hazards such as diseases, wounds, electric shocks, harmful chemicals, contaminated water, etc. sometimes could be fatal [6].

    1. Fast-Moving Water

      Excess amount of surface runoff accumulated in low areas often runs down streets and enters subsurface infrastructures like subways, storm sewers, etc. that results to massive destruction and fatalities.

    2. Electric Shocks

      Live wires contacting extended surface water accumulated in low areas are often causes of electric shocks to people crossing the water covered streets.

    3. Wounds and Infection

      Wounds are common during urban flooding events. The wounds could be cuts by sharp edges or falling objects. Such wounds can be easily infected when contacting with contaminated water.

    4. Contamination

      Chemical spilling from gas stations and vehicles or other types of chemical containers is a common phenomenon during urban flooding. Potential risks include contaminated drinking water induced sickness, allergy to toxic mold growing in wetted houses. Contamination control and remediation is always a big challenge during and after an urban flooding.

    5. Stress and Diseases

      The shock of urban flooding is often powerful on the victims of floods. Stress, lack of rest, contaminated drinking water and diseases passed by dead animals are often cause people sick during especially when medicines are lack.

  4. Flooding Simulation Models

    Many computer models have been developed to simulate the storm induced urban flooding to enhance the prediction and prevention of urban flooding. They can be classified into the following categories [7]:

    1. Drainage Network Models

      A type of models mainly focus on the processes of urban drainage and surface runoff and are based on hydrological methods.

    2. Models Based on Shallow-water Equations

      A group of computer and remote sensing aided models that can be 2D shallow-water models or drainage network coupled with urban surface models or a hydrological model supported by hydrodynamic urban flood model.

    3. Hydrogeomorphic Approaches

      An approach to delineate approximate inundation areas based on terra analysis.

    4. Alternative Methods (Cellular Automata and Neural Networks)

      The development and application of cellular automata and neural networks models are a new trend in urban flooding modeling with a great potential. It is foreseen that machine learning will play a big role in urban flooding prediction in the future.

  5. Risk Prevention

    The risks of urban flooding are real and urgent. Following measures can be explored and implemented to prevent or mitigate the risks:

    1. Urban flooding early warning systems

      Storm induced urban flooding sometime is hard to predict due to the randomness of extreme weather conditions resulted from climate change and the short time window available to develop an emergency response plan to cope a flooding event. Therefore, municipalities should develop an early warning system with triggers to automatically activate the emergency response plan. The early warning systems should include the forecasted amount of rain and duration, the delineation of low areas and their ponding water depth thresholds, identification of vulnerable facilities, infrastructures, sources of contamination, live electric wires, and neighborhoods, etc.

    2. Municipal infostructure upgrade

      Most municipalities have infrastructures built several decades or centuries ago and were not well maintained. Their capacities were well underestimated. As a result, when extreme weather brings a great amount of water that surpasses the capacity of the infrastructures, a localized urban flooding event occurs. With the increase of storm induced urban floods, municipalities should check their existing infrastructures and make necessary upgrades to prevent flooding.

    3. Better design of new municipal infrastructures

      Municipal storm management systems are often designed based on the 100 year return precipitation events, and most urban areas are often over developed with low grass coverage rates. With the on-going climate change, the design criteria such as the designed rain event have to be updated properly to reflect the changes of weather and land surface conditions to prevent potential urban flooding.

    4. Well-designed emergency reaction plans

      A well-designed emergency reaction plan is essential for all municipalities. The plan could dramatically reduce casualties and property damages. The plan should be developed with the help of urban flooding prevention specialists and municipal operation representatives, and all other stakeholders. The reaction plan should also have an education/training program for residents living in urban areas especially in those vulnerable areas to help residents get prepared for flooding events such as the locations of high ground areas to retrieve, the escape routes, the emergency supplies including rain coats, flash lights, safety jackets, ropes, knives, fire starters, foods, water and medicines, boats, communication tools such as fully charged cell phones and chargers, radios, etc.

  6. Conclusion

    Storm induced urban flooding is a great threat to people and their properties in urban areas. With the climate change on going, more frequent and intensive storms could result to more frequent urban flooding events. Urban flooding modeling can be a great tool to be used to improve the design and upgrade of municipal storm water management systems and the development of potential risk mitigation plans.

References:

[1] Types of flooding https://www.iclr.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/ICLR_Flooding_2021.pdf, : Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction (ICLR).

[2] 2021 Henan floods. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Henan_floods#:~:text=On%20July">%2020%2C%20Zhengzhou%2C%20the,and%20over%2050%20missing%20people.

[3] Flooding in Europe. https://climate.copernicus.eu/esotc/2021/flooding-july.

[4] Nicholas Reimann, Forbes Staff, Tropical Storm Elsa Floods New York City Subways As Storm Races Through Northeast. https://www.forbes.com/sites/nicholasreimann/2021/07/09/tropical-storm-elsa-floods-new-york-city-subways-as-storm-races-through-northeast/.

[5] Anna Weber, Environmental Health. What Is Urban Flooding? https://www.nrdc.org/bio/anna-weber.

[6] National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. URBAN FLOODING: Hazards and Tips for Prevention. https://tools.niehs.nih.gov/wetp/public/hasl_get_blob.cfm?ID=13761#:~:text=This%20water%20may%20contact%20open,accidently%2C%20causing%20vomiting%20or%20diarrhea.&text=Mold%20can%20lead%20to%20or,and%20furniture%20in%20flooded%20spaces

[7] Zhi Li, Hanqi Li, etc., 2024. Influence of building collapse on pluvial and fluvial flood inundation of metro stations in central Shanghai. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Key-components-of-urban-flood-modelling_fig3_351917347#:~:text=(2021)%20categorise%20pluvial%20flood%20models,limitations%2C%20and%20strengths%20of%20models.

[8] Kaihua Guo, Mingfu Guan, and Dapeng Yu. 2021. Urban surface water flood modelling – a comprehensive review of current models and future challenges. https://hess.copernicus.org/articles/25/2843/2021/.

Disclamation: The information published in this blog is based on author’s personal knowledge and experience and is provided to readers as references only. The environmental conditions and requirements of regulations could vary from site to site. As such, readers should seek professional advices from a consultant who is familiar with the site conditions when readers address their environmental concerns. The authors of the blogs and GreenRideau Environmental Solutions Inc. are not responsible for any losses or damages resulted from either direct or indirect uses of the information provided in the blogs published on www.greenrideau.com.